Where Men Win Glory

Where Men Win Glory

The Odyssey of Pat Tillman

Book - 2009/09/15
Average Rating:
9
1
Rate this:
Traces the controversial story of NFL player and soldier Pat Tillman, describing the military's efforts to hide the truth about his death by friendly fire, in an account that draws on Tillman's journals and letters as well as interviews with family members and fellow soldiers.
Publisher: New York : Doubleday, 2009/09/15
Edition: 1st ed
ISBN: 9780385522267
0385522266
Branch Call Number: B TILLMAN
Characteristics: 358 p

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

WHERE MEN WIN GLORY is not a bad book, but it is definitely not a Krakauer blockbuster like INTO THE WILD and INTO THIN AIR. Its flaw is that it is several different narratives that never get knit together. You have the back story of football star and thinking man Pat Tillman, which is compelling; then you have an in-depth treatment of the big fratricidal incident in Nasiriyah during the invasion of Iraq in March 2003 the year prior to Tillman's death; then you have the in-depth description of the Army Ranger friendly-fire incident that killed Tillman in Afghanistan; then you have an account of the Army's and the Bush administration's cover-up of the Tillman fratricide and the efforts of Tillman's mother Dannie to have the government investigate itself; and finally you have krakauer's concluding comments on the doomed nature of the U.S./NATO presence in Afghanistan. The best part of the book is reading about Pat Tillman. He was a neat guy, a real person, an honest man. Krakauer is particularly effective when he describes Tillman's rapid disillusionment with the military during basic training at Fort Benning, Georgia. As Tillman wrote in his journal: "I am not a negative man, I do not want to report bad, I want to rise above and bring everyone with me. However, this fucking place blows . . . period." Krakauer hits the right note at the end. Afghanistan is not a conflict that the United States will ever win. Tillman's head was blown off in Khost Province by a brother Ranger operating a squad automatic weapon. Close by, over the Zero Line, a.k.a., Durand Line, is North Waziristan, home to Bin Laden crony and ISI asset Jalaluddin Haqqani, head of the Haqqani network. The United States is fighting a creation of its allies, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia. It is all a crazy murderous game that mangles and discards the lives of young people. I doubt the ongoing Pakistani campaign in North Waziristan is anything more than a perfunctory performance of political theater.

g
gypsytwilight
Feb 27, 2015

I feel as though Krakauer may be glorifying the life of his subject a bit, but even so Tillman was an admirable man and I'm glad to have been given a fuller picture of his life and the circumstances surrounding his death.

g
gemini07
Aug 29, 2012

Insightful biography about NFL player Pat Tillman and the circumstances of his death in Afghanistan. I found some sections a bit repetitive.

t
ThePatelvis
Dec 22, 2010

Inspiring and heartbreaking. An amazing true story that everyone should read.

t
tedrich2921
Nov 08, 2010

This is the third book I've read by this incredibly talented author. It tells the story of how a truly good person did what he thought was right; Pat Tillman is inspirational. However, the larger story is how Americans are manipulated and lied to so that there is support for political decisions that have nothing to do with what people are told. What we are told by our leaders has nothing to do with reality. Although we may think we understand the movitation for military actions in Iraq and Afganistan, we are fed a constant stream of lies and propoganda. If you don't believe me, you owe it to yourself to read this excellent book.

s
seejaneread
Sep 09, 2010

Excellent biography of Pat Tillman. I was living in Phoenix at the time Pat was killed, and he was heavily mourned by the community there. Then I moved to the Bay Area a few years later, where I learned he was quite a public figure as well. I wanted to find out more about him. Jon Kraukauer (author of Into the Wild) tells an excellent story of an iconoclast who felt driven by his ideals and values and never backed down from a challenge. He also showed what really happened behind the friendly fire incidents of both Tillman and Jessica Lynch. A sad ending to an extraordinary life; definitely worth the time, and well told.

h
hscpa333
Apr 18, 2010

One of the best books I have read. Thoroughly researched, insightful, unbiased, great story telling, well organized.

a
andreamcghee
Feb 11, 2010

Detailed and insightful look into the Afghanistan war complications. Krakauer (as usual) shows his engrossing writing skills...although he seems to have a "bone-to-pick" with the Bush administration. Great book.

t
tauseef365
Nov 29, 2009

Equal parts engrossing biography and illuminating expose on the US military, it is an excellent read.

Age

Add Age Suitability

CBearjkn Dec 12, 2011

CBearjkn thinks this title is suitable for 15 years and over

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Recommendations

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at ELPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top