The Submission

The Submission

Large Print - 2011
Average Rating:
Rate this:
Baker & Taylor
A jury gathers in Manhattan to select a memorial for the victims of a devastating terrorist attack. Their fraught deliberations complete, the jurors open the envelope containing the anonymous winner's name - and discover he is an American Muslim. Instantly they are cast into a roiling debate about the claims of grief, the ambiguities of art, and the meaning of Islam. Their conflicted response is only a preamble that of the country.

& Taylor

Selected for a jury that must choose an appropriate memorial for September 11 victims, Claire Harwell struggles to navigate a media firestorm when the winning designer is revealed as an enigmatic Muslim-American.
Selected for a jury that must choose an appropriate memorial for September 11 victims, Claire Harwell, who lost her husband and the father of her children during the attacks, struggles to navigate a media firestorm when the winning designer is revealed as an enigmatic Muslim-American who refuses to represent any beliefs but his own. A first novel. (general fiction).

Publisher: Waterville, Me. : Thorndike Press, 2011
ISBN: 9781410443496
Branch Call Number: L FICTION WALDMAN
Characteristics: 579 p. ; 23 cm


From the critics

Community Activity


Add a Comment

Aug 19, 2013

This novel reflects the contradictions of the US and the conflicted responses to 9/11. In the end, Waldman has a positive perspective on the future. The author was at the Ottawa Writers' Festival shortly after the book was published and was impressive in her presentation of her book.

oO_Oo Aug 02, 2013

I got about 10 pages into this before I realized I read it already. It was pretty unmemorable. The characters are flat and unlikeable, the writing is stiff and the dialogue is wooden.

jeanner222 Mar 20, 2013

It has been two years since the terrorist attack on 9/11. A jure debates the merits of two memorials submitted to the contest; one of these will be erected to memorialize those lost on 9/11. The jury member who represents the families who lost loved ones in the attack is strident in her defense of a garden memorial. She convinces other jurors to vote for the design. And when the garden design is determined to be the winning design, the name of the submission’s architect is revealed: Mohammad Khan.

Can Americans/New Yorkers accept and embrace a 9/11 memorial designed by a man with a Muslim name? Even if he is an American? Can an American with such a name be treated in post-9/11 America?

People from all sides of the issue will weigh in on the memorial and its architect. Obviously, there will be controversy.

This novel received a lot of hype, but I’m just not impressed by it. I guess the plot could have been interesting, if it had not been so obvious. The characters are one-dimensional, and I just could not force myself to care about them.

Jul 31, 2012

Vvery well written and described with great accuracy what might have happened had this scenario (a Muslim wins a contest to design the September 11 World Trade Center memorial) actually played out, but the characters were fairly flat, which made it hard to really get into the book. Still, it was an enjoyable read and, in case anyone is looking, one particularly well suited to book clubs. I definitely wouldn't mind having people to discuss this one with.

Jul 29, 2012

Well-written, good character development, and good plot. I got a bit bogged down in the morass of the prejudices, processes, egos, stereotypes and politics. I ended up skimming the second half. The rest of my book club was far more positive.

Jul 25, 2012

While it started a bit slower than other things I have been reading lately, after a bit I found myself engrossed. A thought provoking book about the prejudices and stereotypes we possess that we may not wish to acknowledge. A great read.

Jul 20, 2012

Interesting perspective on the 911 tragedy and what could have happened. Racially charged, interesting and worth a read. I agree with valency_sterling...good but not great.

Jul 09, 2012

A good book, but shy of "very good" or "great." Even with the twist of events and such, the material didn't feel especially compelling or new. It could definitely generate a lot of discussion and be good for book clubs, but there was some certain spark missing.

geezr_rdr Jul 04, 2012

As the narrative develops we get a great description of the evils unleashed by the events of 9-11 and how these threaten the better angels of our nature. Hang on to the very end to get the full impact of this story.

Jun 18, 2012

June Library book group selection.

View All Comments


Add Age Suitability

There are no ages for this title yet.


Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.


Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.


Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number


Subject Headings


Find it at ELPL

To Top