This was a disappointment. It lacked depth, flow, and a genuine plot.
I had high expectations for The House of Velvet and Glass. Katherine Howe wowed me with The Physick Book of Deliverance Dane so I was expecting more of the same.
That'll teach me! This second book of hers is pretty much nothing like her first. It was slow in development- more than halfway into it, I was wondering if there'd be any element of the supernatural. There is, but it's not crucial to the plot. The plot is basically a drama with a stiff, unconvincing romance thrown in for good measure.
The things I liked:
Touching on the helplessness of grief, and the way it changes people
A female protagonist who is so Type A it's painful
Plot nods to prominent social issues of the nineteen-teens, like women's suffrage, opium addiction, the changing face of lunacy, and the Great War
The things I disliked:
Suuuuper slow plot
Wandering messages (is this about Fate? Grace? Or just an excuse to write about the time period?)
Loose ends too neatly tied up
So you can see, if I went into it assuming it was an historic drama, I would have been pleasantly surprised and perhaps enjoyed it more. I recommend it for fans of nineteen-teens historic fiction, Boston history, and multiple POV & timelines.
Guilt ridden and shut off from the world, it doesn't seem that Sybil can help anyone including herself. The grief that surround her family from the deaths of her mother and sister is not lessened by any of the activities that they pretend to enjoy. Until a seance gives Sybil the tool to look into the future and see beyond her life into the lives of others. What she sees there is rooted in the past; her father has the same gift. And what they know is going to happen will change the family forever. Set in the early 20th century this story weaves a spell adroitly.
I almost put this one down but didn’t because I loved the author’s first book so much. Despite the obviously well researched details, the atmospheric setting, and the potential for a truly gripping story, this book ultimately fell a wee bit flat for me due to its dragging plot and lack of action.
Interesting book for some, not one of my favorites.
Weak, unsympathetic characters, abandoned plot threads. I found this book shallow and unsatisfying, even for a light summer read.
I read her previous book, The Psycik book of Diliverance Dane.
This one was just as good. It had to do with mysticism and the sinking of the Titanic and it's affect on the survivors. I found it to be a very moving story.
I really enjoyed her first book but this one..well, not so much. Perhaps it's the surfeit of all things Titanic that have been around lately or the fact that the plot moves at a snail's pace. I kept waiting for something to happen, something that would tie together all the flashbacks, some thread that would make it all coherent but I must have missed it. Instead, I had to keep putting it down as my eyes kept closing. It lacks the intrigue & surprising turns of her first book so I'm afraid it just didn't hold my interest.
There are no ages for this title yet.
There are no summaries for this title yet.
There are no notices for this title yet.
There are no quotes for this title yet.